How Much Do YOU Control? (Part 2)
Friday, February 29th, 2008If you didn’t have a chance to read Part 1 of this series on the subject of free will, you can read it at www.YourSpiritualJourney.net .
In this message, I want to continue our investigation of free will by focusing on our thoughts. If you’re a devoted follower of self-development principles (as I am), you’ve probably heard a thousand times that we control our thoughts. At first glance, this principle makes a lot of sense, and we adopt the belief that we have considerable free will to think the thoughts we choose to think.
Instead of simply accepting the idea that we control our thoughts, I invite you to investigate this principle anew, and with an open mind. You may come to the same conclusion you reached before you read this message. That’s fine. At least you can say that you made a thorough investigation and considered all of the evidence.
Are you ready? Let’s examine our thoughts and the extent of our control over them. I’m going to ask you to do an exercise. Please have a piece of paper and pen nearby. It’s an exercise that I have read in numerous books and articles – and I found it very revealing when I actually did the exercise.
Turn away from your computer. Sit comfortably, take a few breaths and relax. I want you to clear your mind. You may find it easier to close your eyes, but feel free to keep them open if you wish. Just feel the breath coming in and going out. Let your mind empty to the extent possible.
When you feel very relaxed, sit for three minutes and don’t try to think about anything. You can glance at a clock every now and then to know when the three minutes have expired. Keep your mind “blank” to the extent you are able. During these three minutes, note the thoughts that come up in your mind. Each time a thought comes up, put a mark on the piece of paper. If your eyes had been closed, just open them, put a mark on the paper, and close your eyes again. You don’t have to describe the thought – just put a mark on the paper for each thought that arises.
When the three minutes have expired, count the number of marks on your piece of paper. How many thoughts did you have during those three minutes when you weren’t trying to think about anything? Don’t be concerned with the number – it could be 3, 30 or 100.
Are you surprised by the number of thoughts you had in this three minute period? Are you surprised by the particular thoughts that arose? Were all of the thoughts inter-related and part of a similar pattern — such as thoughts of various family members? Perhaps some of the thoughts were completely unrelated – such as a thought of a family member, quickly followed by something radically different. (such as a person you haven’t seen in years or what you plan to eat for dinner)
I’m not going to offer any comments about how to interpret this exercise until the next message. I don’t want to influence you by suggesting there are certain results you should expect. Begin to do your own analysis about what happened when you attempted to keep your mind free of any thoughts.
We can also learn about our thoughts if we investigate what happens when we dream during sleep. How much control do You have over the thoughts and images that arise while you’re asleep and dreaming? You know that images and thoughts are arising. Yet, You are not selecting them. Who controls these? Who or what is putting them into Your awareness?
People often refer to these thoughts and images as coming from the “subconscious” mind. No matter what name we use to identify the source of these images, they aren’t coming from any conscious thoughts You are controlling. Some other force appears to be putting these images into Your mind.
As we know, these images and thoughts can relate to something we’re facing in our lives right now – or they can be very bizarre and involve people we don’t know or those we haven’t seen for many years. We can have dreams that involve people who are deceased. Some of the plots are wild, to say the least.
Who provides the content of these stories? Who selects the cast members that will appear in our dreams? If thoughts and images can appear without Your effort while you’re asleep, what makes You think they can’t be supplied to You, without Your “permission,” while you’re awake?
In addition, while we’re awake, we’ve all had the experience of having an unrelated thought pop into our mind. For example, you’re at your desk at work doing some paperwork and all of a sudden you think about something else. You think of what you’re going to do later that day, or a person comes to mind. This new subject just appeared, without any effort on Your part. It seemed to interrupt the current thought. Who put this new subject into Your mind?
No matter how you slice it, I think you have to acknowledge that You don’t control all of Your thoughts. We could argue all day about how much control You have, but the idea that You control all of your thoughts seems to be contradicted by our everyday experiences. We’ve just gone through a series of thoughts You don’t control.
That being said, there is at least the illusion that we are controlling many of our thoughts. I’ll be discussing that issue in the next message, where we’ll also take a look at how certain religions and spiritual traditions have approached this issue.
You might find it helpful to re-read Part 1 of this message. If you read these messages without trying to defend your previously held beliefs, you’ll open to a deeper spiritual connection. This path can be uncomfortable or scary at first, but your efforts will be rewarded.
And, if you think this entire inquiry is a bunch of nonsense and not worthy of your time, that’s fine, too. I don’t think I have much control over which choice You make!
– Jeff Keller
© 2008
