I received many comments in response to my article, The Twitter Phenomenon (March 24, 2009).
The vast majority of the comments were “anti-Twitter.” However, several readers reported positive aspects about Twitter. I’m glad that both views were presented. I can’t include all of the comments, but here are excerpts from some of them.
Reader Comments:
I agree with this article. I haven’t heard of Twitter until this message, but it amazes me that people are so self-centered to want to be a part of these groups, Facebook included. These sites tend to bring more stress, suck up your precious time AND cause damage at some point. I am so thankful and blessed that I have done the work a long time ago to become more spiritual and connected to what really matters and to be so happy and balanced in my self, my quietness, etc. It’s not an easy road to get to…but so worthwhile. I think if these people did the work as well, they would find more satisfaction within themselves and their surroundings than any of these sites could ever offer.
* * * *
Oh how I love your article, especially the last line “True connection is found through a quiet mind, not a mind caught up in trivial facts”. My sentiments exactly. Am so glad that there is someone who feels twittering and the likes of it are such busy state of mind.
* * * *
Thanks for excellent post.
Following things happen out of our awareness:
1. Our mind is engaged/active all the time with useless information. We are not thinking creative thoughts.
2. We are stopped at the level of mind, enjoying the feeds and being active in the game. We are not really looking beyond mind.
* * * *
I heard about Twitter this morning on the news. A hospital is using the service to update families on their loved one while in surgery. We have become such an instant society — and cannot wait for anything. I agree with your assessment. We are not allowing time to meditate and seek and trust God to take care of our family and friends while we are away or in surgery or taking a walk, etc.
Jeff’s Reply to this comment:
A strange thought came to me while reading your comment about using Twitter in the hospital to update someone on a family member’s surgery. On one level, it is nice to get such an update. However, I don’t suppose the hospital would post this message in the middle of the operation:
“Complication — patient has stopped breathing”
* * * *
I agree with a lot of what you say about Twitter. I certainly don’t care if someone is eating breakfast or what they had for breakfast. However, I am on Twitter and most of the people I follow have something to offer me in terms of information dealing with web sites, blogging, etc, which is where my interests are.
* * * *
My husband and I were wondering the other day what “Twitter” was. We both do not like all these gadgets and gizmos in today’s world. Many are valuable beyond anything imaginable but I feel we don’t need phones in our ears constantly and/or twittering or texting about what I am doing in the bathroom. Maybe if all that wasted energy and time was harnessed into something positive for someone else, our world would be better for it.
* * * *
I absolutely agree with you on this one. I take it even further, and don’t answer the phone if I don’t feel like talking to someone (Caller ID helps). I just don’t see the point in being available to everyone 24/7 unless there’s a crisis. I need peace and quiet for Yoga and Reiki – in short, I need ‘alone time’ or I’m unable to function.
* * * *
Teens are “Twittering,” as are some adults… but even more adults are “social networking” and “business networking” on Facebook, My Space, Linked In, and others. WHEN do we ever simply “Talk” to a friend or business contact face-to-face? You’ll hear people say, ‘don’t have time!” I had an in-person breakfast meeting with a colleague last Wednesday. She was amazed afterward about how good it felt to “really connect.” YEA! Ya think! We actually talked!
People don’t have time if they are doing all this emailing, texting, and posting. UGH!
I’m with you… this I can resist.
* * * *
You, my friend, were way off on your assessment of Twitter.
It’s a powerful networking, business building and information tool.
I’ve been able to sell books and audios, make new networking connections, keep up with friends, learn all sorts of things, and much more on Twitter.
I can’t explain it but it’s pretty amazing.
* * * *
It is so sad that people are so engrossed in this twitter stuff. What if we get connected with that Great Almighty Creator and learn to go back to nature…smell the scent of flowers and enjoy the colorful butterflies, star gaze and see the beauty of the sky in a quiet cool night…touch your soul, reach out to heavens…the firmament…far far beyond. Drown yourself in the beauty of HIS Creation…yes…maybe this will be a better “twitter.”
“Mauna Brata”…silence is the language of the soul!
* * * *
Beautifully put! As the world melts down in egoic mind madness around us I get told via Facebook that an old work colleague of mine has done a Facebook quiz and determined what her “Stripper Name” should be! This is a woman in her 40’s with small children and I am sure not a huge amount of free time to begin with….certainly less now with Facebook quizzes to be taken. Well…must put my mind at rest on this issue and get away from mental activity about it.
* * * *
What a shame people are resorting to using social networking sites debasing languages and face to face skills.
You can question the reasons for this, such as the latest fad, addiction, loneliness, lack of spirituality and so on.
Have parents become less responsible for coaching and mentoring their children? I’d be interested to read other subscribers opinions. I just think it’s a tragedy such sites are becoming more influential and also reality TV programmes.
* * * *
You are right, there is a lot of nonsensical chatter on twitter, but it is also a really great tool.
When you first join, it doesn’t make any sense. Then when you start searching around for topics that interest you, you find there is a wealth of information and people willing to help with your needs.
For example, I am trying to figure out Wordpress Blogging. I searched Twitter for Wordpress. It brings up a stream talking about Wordpress. I click on someone’s name and read what they have posted. I look at their profile which usually contains their website and a short bio. If it looks like they are having a conversation and information on what I am looking for I ask them a question by using @theirname, which posts it to their profile where everyone that is following them can see it and then I will get replies from people who have information and answers for me. I have met a few very valuable contacts that way, some who have helped me immensely with Wordpress. Most of the business people that are on Twitter are very generous with information and solutions to problems. This directs attention to their websites and products in an indirect way.
I have different interests and have been able to find a variety of people on Twitter to network with: photographers, writers, book publishers, Drudge Report, Michelle Malkin, Christians, social media marketers, bloggers, artists… The world is limitless.
* * * *
AMEN!!!
I couldn’t agree with you more, Jeff.
I’m totally astounded by this nonsense, my mouth open in amazement at the self importance of this ridiculousness.
* * * *
Final Comment from Jeff:
Thanks again to all those who submitted comments. Although I might be wrong, I get the sense that most of the subscribers to this newsletter choose not to use Twitter. This doesn’t make you better or worse than anyone else, it simply shows that your interests lie elsewhere or that you don’t see Twitter as a valuable use of your time.
I can easily see how Twitter could increase your networking contacts, bring you more business or provide helpful resources. What I still can’t understand is the need to include the ridiculous minutiae of day to day activity. I simply don’t see what that adds, yet it is one of the main things Twitter is known for.
When it comes to Twitter, I will remain on the sidelines. Too much mind stuff for me.
– Jeff Keller